Book Review: The Lost Night by Andrea Bartz
The Lost Night has not gotten a lot of hype around the bookish community. This was a friend’s recommendation and I must say I didn’t hate it. It was not the most mind blowing book in the world but it was an enjoyable read. Andrea Bartz was an unknown author for me to read and to be honest I don’t know if I would read anything else from her. She was originally a journalist and co-author of a book called Stuff Hipsters Hate. Her other fiction novel is the Herd and its sounds meh.
The story starts off as a self narrator Edie reveals that she is not the happy go lucky socialite everyone thinks she is. It’s a diary style entry that also tells us she is not very connected with her friend Lindsay anymore. Then bam Edie is dead, thought to be a suicide!. Fast forward to present day. Lindsay and Sarah- a friend from Edie days, reconnect around the time of Edie’s death anniversary. Lindsay finds out that Sarah didn’t think Edie’s death was a suicide. She found Edie in her underwear which was very strange to her as Edie was always put together. She also found a gin drink in her right hand however she was left handed.
This sparks Lindsay to feel nostalgic and she starts to read over all her old emails from Edie. The reader notices the power difference between the two in the friendship. Turns out Lindsay was actually going to ‘break up’ with Edie. Edie was overbearing and bossy. Lindsay then found her flip cam and watched everyone bad mouthing Edie the night she died! Alex- Edie’s ex boyfriend at the time was also vocal about his dislike for Edie. Doubt seems to be creeping up as to who was responsible for Edie’s death.
Greg- another friend from the group- point of view comes through. He met Edie by chance and became instantly infatuated with her over Craig’s list. Greg thought that Lindsay was a creepy brunette roommate. At this point the reader is starting to get suspicious of so many people in Edie’s death, especially Lindsay. We find out that Lindsay grew up in a right wing family very comfortable with guns. The gun that killed Edie belonged to another friend from the group Kevin and was easily accessible.
We find out that Edie had a miscarriage and Kevin was the one who took her to the hospital. She was dating Alex at the time and cheated on him with Lloyd, whom Lindsay liked. Linday found out about Lloyd by talking to Edie’s mother. Lindsay is being a little detective trying to find the truth of the night no one can remember. This book outlines each circle of friends have dirty secrets and brings to light the question of how well you can really know someone.
Edie was dating this older gentleman for along time – Greg. While Lindsay was stalking him to find out what he knew about Edie’s secrets she stumbles upon Josh. He is cute and asked her out ! More detective work goes on and Lindsay thinks that Alex is being shady when he says that he was okay with his and Edie’s breakup- especially since she has seen the lost footage of everyone trash talking Edie. Is she being paranoid as everyone seems guilty of having a beef with Edie. Which beef is big enough for murder?
So the video clip where everyone was bashing Edie had some inaudible parts in a different location. Lindsay’s friend put it through filters and where they heard’ heavy senile skies’ turns into be ‘ have you seen Alex!”. So Alex was missing the night Edie died. Now as a reader my suspicion is so confused. I started off thinking it was Lindsay and now I may think it was Alex. Great writing technique!
Talking to Kevin Lindsay found out that after her miscarraige Edie confessed to him it would suck to die young because you have not truly lived. Why would she then commit suicide. Trying to find the truth Lindsay confronted Alex. He said that Edie had flunked out of the spring term and her mother found out and showed up trying to convince her daughter to come home.
So trying to figure out Edie’s death Lindsay, Sarah and Alex are all having lunch together. Sarah thinks that Lindsay is being paranoid. Sarah says Edie was just a shitty friend and she told Sarah Lindsay’s deepest secret. The Warsaw incident was that Lindsay clawed someone’s face while she was drunk. We also see her anger come out when Lindsay goes out with Josh gets drunk and pushes him into traffic.
Teresa is Lindsays good friend and is trying to help Lindsay with all this confusion. She helps hangover Lindsay and tries to comfort her asking her to give up this wild goose chase. Lindsay finds an email on her computer sent from Edie? Teresa puts a tracker on her computer and finds out Lindsay sent it to herself. Now Lindsay is crazy and blows up at Teresa. She is pushing people away just like Edie did. We also learn from Teresa that Lindsay was a troubled child and pushed her mother down they stairs. Seems like Lindsay has a violent past. Now my suspicion is placed back on Lindsay. The author is great at redirecting the murder suspect keeping the reader intriuged.
We are now at the climax of this book and what a twist we read. Teresa goes all psycho on Lindsay. It seems like Teresa is trying to make Lindsay paranoid and blame herself but we learn that Teresa is really Jenna – Edies old roommate!. She killed Edie because Edie dropped her from the friend group then moved out. She started dealing drugs for a local named Anthony. This is how she was able to get close again to Edie asking for forgiveness then bam shot her staging it as a suicide.
Jenna/Teresa then befriended Lindsay to keep tabs on her- Lindsay saw everything that night but was too drunk to remember. Jenna used Lindsay’s sketchy past to keep the suspicion on Lindsay and off her. Drugged Lindsay goes to shoot Jenna and blacks out ending up in the hospital. Here is where things get really confusing for Lindsay. When she wakes up ‘Teresa’ says she had another drunken moment like Warsaw and Josh and shot Teresa by mistake. What do we believe as the reader. Is the previous event just a figment of Lindsays’ imagination or did they really happen?
Lindsay spills water on her laptop. She takes it to a Geek squad to get fixed and learned that Teresa is actually tracking her every move. She confronts Teresa about this and we learn than once again Teresa is really Jenna! Jenna is arrested and Lindsay now tries to heal from all this craziness.
So this book was really good at confusing the reader. It made use distrust the voice of the narrator- Lindsay- by making us question the dependability of Lindsay’s perspective. By making up question the sanity of the narrator it also made us question whether she was a reliable storyteller. I really liked the twist at the end which made me even more confused and the suspension was great. What did you all think of this book. Yay or nay? Please feel free to leave comments below! I would love to hear from you!